Two bidders read the same tender. One sees "Cyber Essentials" and books a self-assessment. The other assumes that means "Plus", quotes a four-figure audit into their costs, delays their bid by six weeks waiting for an assessor, and loses the contract to the first bidder, who was compliant all along.
The names are confusingly similar and the gap between them is large: in cost, in time, and in what you have to prove. This article sets out what each level is, what UK buyers actually ask for, and how to decide which you need.
The same five controls, two ways of proving them
Both levels are built on the same five technical controls set by the NCSC. The NCSC overview and the certification body's Cyber Essentials Plus page are the places to confirm anything here; the scheme is updated from time to time.
- Firewalls: every device behind a boundary firewall, including the software firewall on remote workers' laptops.
- Secure configuration: unnecessary software removed, default passwords changed, strong authentication in place.
- User access control: individual accounts, admin accounts used only for admin tasks, multi-factor authentication on every cloud service.
- Malware protection: up-to-date protection on every in-scope device, with built-in Windows and macOS protection acceptable.
- Security update management: supported software only, high and critical updates applied within 14 days.
The difference is not what you have to do. It is how you prove you have done it.
Cyber Essentials: declared
You complete a self-assessment questionnaire about your IT, truthfully. A board member or equivalent signs a declaration that the answers are accurate. A certification body reviews the answers, may ask follow-up questions, and issues the certificate if the answers meet the requirements.
Nobody tests your devices. The certification rests on your honesty and your understanding of your own estate. That is not a weakness of the scheme; it is the design. It makes the baseline achievable for a five-person firm with no IT department, which is the point.
Cyber Essentials Plus: tested
You first pass Cyber Essentials. Then, within a fixed window after that pass (currently three months), an assessor independently verifies a sample of your devices. The audit typically includes:
- an external vulnerability scan of your internet-facing systems
- an internal scan of sampled devices to check for missing patches
- checks that malware protection is installed, running and up to date
- tests of email and browser defences: can a test file with malicious characteristics get through?
- confirmation of account and MFA configuration on sampled devices and services
If a sampled laptop is missing a critical update that was released more than 14 days ago, that is a finding. Depending on severity and number, findings may mean remediation and re-test, or a fail.
What UK public sector tenders actually ask for
The default is Cyber Essentials
Central government buyers have required the basic certificate from suppliers handling certain types of information for over a decade. That requirement has flowed down through local government, the NHS, education, housing and the arm's-length bodies, and through the prime contractors that supply them.
In the overwhelming majority of tenders where cyber certification appears at all, the requirement is Cyber Essentials: the self-assessed level.
In the tender: if it says "Cyber Essentials" without "Plus", that is what is required. Do not read "Plus" into it.
Where Plus appears
Plus tends to be required where the contract carries higher risk:
- Defence and security-related supply chains, where contractors are expected to meet the higher level and flow it down to subcontractors handling sensitive material.
- Health and care, particularly contracts involving access to patient systems or clinical networks.
- Critical national infrastructure suppliers in energy, water, transport and telecoms.
- Larger frameworks and lots, where the buyer sets Plus as the bar for the whole framework regardless of what each call-off involves.
- Buyers who have had an incident, and have raised the bar in response. This is becoming more common.
The tender will say so explicitly. It may also say "Cyber Essentials Plus or equivalent", in which case ISO 27001 certification is sometimes accepted, but do not assume; ask through the clarification process.
The timing phrase matters as much as the level
In the tender: "Must hold Cyber Essentials Plus at the time of submission" is a very different proposition from "must hold Cyber Essentials prior to commencement." The first may rule you out of this bid; the second gives you weeks or months.
Whichever level is named, check when it is required: at submission, at award, or at commencement.
Cost and time, side by side
| Cyber Essentials | Cyber Essentials Plus | |
|---|---|---|
| What is assessed | Your answers to a questionnaire | Your actual devices and systems, sampled |
| Who assesses | Certification body reviews your answers | Independent assessor tests, on site or remotely |
| Certification fee | Hundreds of pounds, banded by organisation size | Four figures typically; scales with devices and sites |
| Preparation effort | Know your estate, fix the gaps, answer accurately | As above, plus every sampled device must pass a live test |
| Time | Days to weeks, depending on how many gaps you start with | Weeks; must be completed within three months of the basic pass |
| Prerequisite | None | A current Cyber Essentials pass |
| Valid for | 12 months | 12 months |
The certification fee for the basic level is a fixed, published amount. The Plus fee is a quote, because it depends on how much assessor time your estate needs.
Watch out: preparation cost is the hidden difference. With the basic certificate, a device with a slightly lagging update is something you fix before answering the question. With Plus, the assessor may find it first.
Which should you get?
Get Cyber Essentials first, always
You have to anyway, because Plus requires it, and for most small bidders it is the only level any tender has ever asked them for. It is also where the real work is: scoping the estate, turning on MFA everywhere, retiring unsupported devices, separating admin accounts, getting patching under control. Do that properly and Plus becomes an audit of things you already did, not a scramble.
Add Plus when it earns something
Reasons that justify the extra cost and time:
- A tender or framework you want to bid for names it.
- A prime contractor you supply requires it as a flow-down condition.
- Your cyber insurer offers better terms for it.
- You handle data sensitive enough that your customers would reasonably expect independent verification, and saying so wins business.
Reasons that do not: "it sounds more impressive", or the assumption that buyers prefer it when they have not said so. Buyers who need Plus ask for it. Buyers who ask for Cyber Essentials are satisfied by Cyber Essentials.
Plan the Plus window
If you know you will need Plus, time the basic self-assessment so the three-month window lands when you can host the audit.
Watch out: passing the self-assessment in July and then discovering nobody can book an assessor until November means doing the self-assessment again.
What Plus tests that self-assessment declares
Understanding the audit helps whichever level you are going for, because it tells you what "compliant" means in concrete terms.
Firewalls. Self-assessment: you declare that the software firewall is enabled on remote workers' laptops. Plus: the assessor checks the setting on sampled devices. The fix is the same either way: turn it on and keep it on.
Secure configuration. Self-assessment: you declare default passwords are changed and auto-run is disabled. Plus: the assessor may check whether a standard user can run software from removable media on a sampled device.
User access control. Self-assessment: you declare MFA is on for all cloud services. Plus: the assessor confirms it for sampled accounts. The shared admin login that nobody has got round to removing will be found.
Malware protection. Self-assessment: you declare protection is on and updating. Plus: the assessor tests whether a sampled device blocks test files delivered by email and by browser download. Built-in protection passes this when it is correctly configured.
Security update management. Self-assessment: you declare high and critical updates are applied within 14 days. Plus: a vulnerability scan of sampled devices shows whether they are. This is the control most likely to produce a Plus finding, and the reason automatic updates on every device matter.
In the cloud: at both levels every cloud service you use is in scope. The self-assessment asks you to list them and to say, for each, whether MFA is available and enforced; the Plus assessor checks MFA on sampled cloud accounts. The provider patches the service; your devices, browsers and any rented servers are yours.
Decide, then move
Read the tender. Find the level and the timing phrase. If it says Cyber Essentials, get Cyber Essentials and do not pay for an audit nobody asked for. If it says Plus, get Cyber Essentials first, fast, and book the audit inside the window. Either way, the first step is knowing where your estate stands against the five controls today.